ANALYSIS OF POPE FRANCIS'S STATEMENTS REGARDING THE RUSSO-UKRAINIAN WAR

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17721/sophia.2024.23.4

Keywords:

Vatican, Ukraine, war, international politics, Catholicism

Abstract

B a c k g r o u n d . The position of the Vatican regarding the Russian-Ukrainian war, its influence on international politics, and internal processes in Ukraine are being studied. The research examines the Vatican's diplomatic approach, which seeks to maintain neutrality and promote dialogue between the conflicting parties. An analysis of Vatican statements regarding the war in Ukraine, reactions to them from other countries and Ukrainian society has been conducted.

M e t h o d s . The study employs a complex of methods: historical analysis to examine the evolution of the Vatican's position (2014–2024), content analysis of Pope Francis's statements, comparative method to juxtapose different parties' stances, systems approach to consider the Vatican's influence on international and domestic politics of Ukraine, expert evaluation method, and statistical analysis of sociological data. This comprehensive approach allowed for a thorough investigation of the Vatican's position on the course of the Russo-Ukrainian war and its perception by the international community.

R e s u l t s . The study investigates the reasons behind the Vatican's position, such as the Catholic Church's pacifist doctrine, the desire to avoid unequivocal assessments, and the influence of Pope Francis's personal background and ideological views. The research also aims to clarify Pope Francis's influence on the internal political situation in Ukraine. Research period: 2014–2024, with a focus on two stages: 2014–2022 (hybrid war and local conflict); 2022–2024 (full-scale war). Main research results: The Vatican avoids calling Russia as an aggressor and does not condemn its actions. Pope Francis seeks reconciliation and proposes that the conflicting parties sit down for negotiations. The Vatican's position on the Russian-Ukrainian war is based on Catholic dogma, where evil does not have a substantive nature; the ideological views of Pope Francis (anti- Americanism, Latin American context); the general tendency in the Catholic Church towards forgiveness, laid down by John Paul II, and pacifism. The research reveals that the Vatican's stance has faced criticism from both Western countries and Ukrainian society, as it is perceived as equating the aggressor with the victim.

C o n c l u s i o n s . The Vatican does not have a significant influence on the decisions of world states. The position of the Bishop of Rome may influence public opinion in countries with a high level of religiosity. In Ukraine, the Vatican's position does not have considerable support from the Roman Catholic and Greek Catholic communities, and generally from Ukrainian citizens. The Vatican's position on the Russian-Ukrainian war is amorphous because it does not contain a clear moral assessment and equates the aggressor with the victim; therefore, criminal actions are condemned, but not their cause (Russia).

References

apologies of the Pope to the world. (2001, October 26). Ukrainska Pravda [in Ukrainian]. https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2001/10/26/2984748/

Accattoli, L. (1998). When a Pope asks forgiveness: The Mea Culpa's of John Paul II. Pauline Books & Media.

Bettiza, S, & Gozzi, L. (2023, May 13). Ukraine war: Pope tells Zelensky he is "praying for peace". BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/ world-europe-65581170

Cahill, L. S. (2018). The future of (catholic) just war theory: Marginal. Expositions, 12.1, 20–32. https://expositions.journals.villanova.edu/article/ download/2318/2222

Cary, Ph. (2019). Augustine on evil. In T. Nys, S. de Wijze (Eds.), The Routledge handbook of the philosophy of evil (pp. 30–41). Routledge.

Chiappa, C. (2023, August 28). Pope slammed for telling Russians to hold on to "legacy" of a "Great Empire". Politico. https://www.politico.eu/ article/pope-francis-russia-youth-legacy-empire/

Chyzhyk, Y. (2023, May 13). The desire of the Pope to urgently end the war at any cost is supported by 9 % of Ukrainians – survey. Mirror of the week. Ukraine [in Ukrainian]. https://zn.ua/ukr/war/prahnennja-papi- rimskoho-terminovo-pripiniti-vijnu-za-bud-jaku-tsinu-pidtrimuje-9-ukrajintsiv- opituvannja.html#

EU diplomacy chief comments on remarks about "white flag" for Ukraine: Pope has entered garden where no one invited him. (2024, March 14). Ukrainska Pravda. https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2024/03/14/7446516/

Full text of joint declaration signed by Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill. (2016, February 12). Catholic News Agency. https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/ news/33401/full-text-of-joint-declaration-signed-by-pope-francis-and-patriarch- kirill

Kirchgaessne, S. (2015a, June 10). Pope Francis tells Putin: "sincere" peace efforts needed for Ukraine. Guardian News & Media. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/10/pope-francis-putin-sincere- peace-effort-ukraine-russia-vatican

Kirchgaessne, S. (2015b, June 10). Pope Francis urged to take tougher stance against Vladimir Putin. Guardian News & Media. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/10/pope-francis-urged-to-take- tougher-stance-against-vladimir-putin

Kudryk, N. (2023, May 13). Zelensky's visit to Pope Francis. What are the results? Radio Liberty [in Ukrainian]. https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/ zelanskyy-papa-rymskyy-viyna/32410396.html

Martens, K. (2006). The position of the Holy See and Vatican City State in international relations. University of Detroit law review, 83(5), 729–760.

Marynovych, M. (2022, April 13). The cross of Abel and the cross of Cain are different crosses. Ukrainian Catholic University. https://ucu.edu.ua/ en/news/hrest-avelya-i-hrest-kayina-tse-rizni-hresty/

Melkozerova, V. (2024, March 11). Pope's "white flag" gaffe triggers outrage in Ukraine. Politico. https://www.politico.eu/article/pope-francis- courage-raising-white-flag-remark-sparks-fury-ukraine/

Mullen, Sh. (2024, March 9). Vatican: Pope Francis' "white flag" remark a call for negotiations, not Ukraine's surrender. Catholic News Agency. https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/257048/vatican-pope-francis- white-flag-ukraine-war-negotiations

Poll: How do Poles assess Pope Francis' words about Ukraine and the "white flag"? (2024, March 17). Rzeczpospolita. https://www.rp.pl/ spoleczenstwo/art40007431-sondaz-jak-polacy-oceniaja-slowa-papieza- franciszka-o-ukrainie-i-bialej-fladze

Riga, P. (1966). Catholic Pacifism. The Proceedings of the Catholic Theological Societ y of America, 21, 165.

Rinkēvičs,E. [@edgarsrinkevics]. (2024, March 10). [My Sunday morning take: One must not capitulate in face of evil, one must fight it and defeat it, so] [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/edgarsrinkevics/status/176671642 4725107050

Sikorski,R. [@sikorskiradek]. (2024, March 10). [How about, for balance, encouraging Putin to have the courage to withdraw his army from Ukraine? Peace would immediately ensue] [Video attached] [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/sikorskiradek/status/1766757253502169360

Statement of the Permanent Synod of the UGCC in light of the interview of Pope Francis conducted by Radio Télévision Suisse. (2024, March 10). Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. https://ugcc.ua/en/data/ statement-of-the-permanent-synod-of-the-ugcc-in-light-of-the-interview-of- pope-francis-conducted-by-radio-tlvision-suisse-955/

Stations of the Cross in the Coliseum: voices of peace from war-torn areas. (2023, April 07). Vatican news [in Ukrainian]. https://www.vaticannews.va/ uk/pope/news/2023-04/rozdumy-na-hresnu-dorogu-2023.html

Ukrainian Archbishop calls on Christians to help end conflict. (2015, February 23). Vatican Radio. https://www.archivioradiovaticana.va/storico/ 2015/02/23/ukrainian_archbishop_calls_on_christians_to_help_end_conflict/ en-1125231

Zelensky, V. (2024, March 10). More air defense systems and means of destruction of Russian aviation bring peace closer – address by the President of Ukraine. President of Ukraine. Official website [in Ukrainian]. https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/bilshe-sistem-ppo-ta-zasobiv-urazhennya- rosijskoyi-aviaciyi-89621

Published

2024-12-10

How to Cite

КОСТЮК, О. (2024). ANALYSIS OF POPE FRANCIS’S STATEMENTS REGARDING THE RUSSO-UKRAINIAN WAR. SOPHIA. Human and Religious Studies Bulletin, 23(1), 19-25. https://doi.org/10.17721/sophia.2024.23.4